staceyharding.blog-city.com

Connectivity Debriefed

posted Tuesday, 20 May 2008
My first reaction to this blog was “huh?” because I didn’t (and still don’t) understand many of the applications he talked about.  However, once I listened to the whole thing, I was able to overlook the bits and pieces that didn’t make perfect sense to me and examine the overall picture and the parts of the presentation that resonated the most.  

In a couple different parts of the presentation, Siemens references subjectivity in learning and in our perceptions.  He uses a picture of a network to provide a graphic for his discussion of nodes, and how we are always viewing a situation from a particular node.  In order to further our comprehension of a topic, it is necessary to at least be able to recognize that fact to attempt to incorporate other nodes, or points of view.  This is a main goal of mine as an educator.  I hope to at least make students aware of the wide world out there, and that people have different, and very valid opinions and life styles that may be different than their own.  

He later talks about this further in discussing some of the downfalls of Web 2.0 and educational technology.  He notes that we often find ourselves in an “echo chamber” in that we only seek out information that we agree with.  By only hearing opinions that are the same as our own, we are not deepening our understanding, and our perceptions do not widen.  I would say that most people I know do this, including myself, definitely.  With all the choices that are out there, I seek information from sources that I know I will agree with or at least be sympathetic to, limiting my ability to really learn and be exposed to different perspectives.

Another main piece that I took from this presentation was the focus on learning being part of a network, instead of residing solely within an individual.  Siemens also notes the importance of recognizing this fact to both lessen the responsibility we might feel to know everything, and to widen our perspectives.  

Lastly, the idea that most resonated with me was when the idea of decision making being a learning process in itself, and that learning is not predecided.  I think that many times in the classroom, the focus is often on the content, and what they “must know” that we often do not focus as much on the process.  Connectivity, however, allows us to learn through decision- making and fine-tuning.

In his discussion of what is to happen in the future, Siemens mentions the necessity for a centering agent to be in place to bring the programs together in a more usable fashion for the non-technically inclined.  In our online discussions, I often am exposed to many programs that seem extremely useful, but a bit overwhelming in their scope.  A centering agent would certainly appeal to me in order to make the programs seem a bit more attainable.   Overall, I am curious to see where the future will lead us and I am definitely open to the possibilities.  




1. Terry Smith left...
Sunday, 25 May 2008 6:08 am

Stacey - you said: "the idea that most resonated with me was when the idea of decision making being a learning process in itself, and that learning is not predecided. " I think that is where a some of the controversy with Siemens begins. The huge focus on content, especially today with standardized testing, does seem to result in less vibrant classrooms. Siemans would say that the content must take a back seat to the networking, that new forms of knowledge will emerge. Maybe so, but then educators ask where is the consistency? What is it that we are targeting, and so forth. I don't think we can ever do away with content, obviously, but we can embed it in a different learning process, as you said through decision making and fine tuning.

Siemens' comments about joining our own clubs and expounding on what we already believe in are, as we know, nothing new in our society; we all do tend to group around shared ideas, form clubs, etc. And this is becoming even more prevalent with social networking.


2. jackrich25 left...
Wednesday, 11 June 2008 2:52 am

Stacey,

When I read "huh" on you blog, I went into my own echo chamber. As I kept on reading I felt that we both agree in many areas. I have to admit some of module I listen to twice, and other I still have questions about. However I love the idea of having experts in my social network. I do not feel that the person my have all of the same values as I do. But I would like them to be a person that is extremely knowledgeable about a particular area I am not familiar with.


3. peter2964 left...
Tuesday, 17 June 2008 3:39 pm

Stacey,

I thought you broke down Siemens presentation well. As I was listening to it, I too had questions about what he was talking about. I like that you were able to be honest and open about how you felt in regards to the "echo chamber" I find myself doing the same thing as you. It is much easier and takes less energy to agree with what you are ingesting. My favorite part of this presentation was the discussion about networks; I talk about it in my blog. If you get a chance read my blog and give me some feedback on this topic.